Katherine Jenkins In Victoria Beckham Dress

After she took to Twitter to deny rumours (that many people hadn't even heard of) that she had an affair with David Beckham, some reports suggested that Katherine Jenkins was removed from the 'approved' list of celebrities to receive Victoria Beckham freebies.

But that didn't stop the Welsh songstrel turning heads in a cornflower blue autumn 2012 dress by the former Spice Girl, she paired it with nude platforms and a taupe handbag.

while Victoria herself wore the dress which retails for around £1,650 at a Vanity Fair party back in February 2012.  VB completed the look with a  leather belt around her waist, an Open-toe over-the-knee boots and a side swept ponytail.
The question is "Who wore it better"?